66 in 52: A One Year Chronological Journey Through the Bible

The Last Munchkin

Nancy Prante taught English and creative writing at Clarkston High School, and she was my favorite teacher. This was her photo from my 1985 yearbook. She had steel-gray hair, intense dark eyes, and, as I remember her, a passing resemblance to Angela Lansbury.

She once claimed to have been cast as one of the Munchkins in the 1939 film The Wizard of Oz. We were pretty sure she was lying, but the wonderful thing about Ms. Prante was that we couldn’t be sure. I recently found her obituary and discovered that she was born in 1934. She would have been four years old when the movie was filmed, so maybe she was one of the baby Munchkins in the flower bed.

So now I’m not nearly as sure she was kidding.

She could say something outrageous like that with a completely straight face, leaving you to decide for yourself whether she was serious.

She was delightful. She wasn’t one of those teachers who tried to become everybody’s favorite by being funny. Her humor was dry and deadpan, and she didn’t seem particularly concerned about whether you got the joke.

She was my creative writing teacher at Clarkston High School, and she loved literature.

For an entire semester, she spent part of every class period reading Charles Dickens’s A Tale of Two Cities aloud to us. I think she was trying to get us to appreciate Dickens the way his original readers did—in serialized form.

I don’t remember how far we got each day, or whether she assigned us additional reading between classes. What I remember is the pleasure of sitting there listening to her read. We weren’t analyzing symbolism or preparing for a standardized test. At least, that’s not what I remember. We were listening to a story.

I can’t imagine how a teacher today would justify spending that much classroom time reading a novel aloud. But I’m glad she did. It put me in the same emotional place as those subscribers to All the Year Round in 1859, waiting with bated breath to find out what would happen next to Sydney Carton, Charles Darnay, and wondering what the deal was with Madame Defarge’s knitting.

When the touring company of the musical Camelot played at the Fox Theater (with Richard Harris as Arthur, no less), Ms. Prante overheard me telling a classmate how badly I wanted to see it. After the bell rang, she said, ominously, “Mr. Jackson, please see me after class.” I had no idea what to expect. I was guessing she was concerned about some dark theme in my creative writing notebook I had turned in.

Instead, she said, “If you could go see Camelot, when would you be able to go?”

I thought about my work schedule at Red Lobster, where I bussed tables. I knew Saturdays were peak nights, so I told her I thought a Saturday matinee would work.

That was all.

The next day, she handed me an envelope containing two tickets to Camelot and a one word note: “Enjoy.”

I wish I could remember what I said. I hope I thanked her properly. But I was a teenager, and teenagers aren’t always particularly good at recognizing the significance of someone’s generosity.

She hadn’t announced anything to the class. She hadn’t made a big deal out of it. She had simply overheard something that mattered to one of her students, and quietly made it possible.

I don’t know how much those tickets cost her. I don’t know whether she had some connection that made them available. I only know she gave them to me, and I’ve never forgotten it.

I also know that “This is the time of King Arthur, and we reach for the stars! This is the time of King Arthur, when violence is not strength and compassion is not weakness” weakness has become something of a moral compass for me, especially in recent years when I’ve watched those virtues increasingly dismissed as liabilities. We have chosen Arthur’s first, worst impulse (I shan’t be wounded and not return it in kind. I’m done with feeble hoping! I demand a man’s vengeance) over the better angels of Arthur’s nature he spoke next.

And I have Ms. Prante and the Saturday matinee at the Fox to thank for that.

But the thing I remember most about Ms. Prante was something she wrote in the margin of one of my papers.

I don’t remember the assignment. I don’t remember what I wrote. I don’t remember the grade.

I remember seven words.

You are a graceful writer, Mr. Jackson.

I’ve carried those words with me ever since.

And I’ve come to realize that the word that mattered most wasn’t writer.

It was graceful.

She could have said I was a good writer. She could have said I was talented, or skilled, or promising.

She could even have said, Your writing is graceful.

But she didn’t.

You are a graceful writer.

She made the adjective describe me, not just something I’d written.

And that mattered.

I was a teenager trying to figure out who I was. My older sister Susan had been one of the stars of Clarkston High School, and I had arrived a few years later with the dubious distinction of being Susan Jackson’s little brother. Teachers remembered her. They expected great things from me.

Unfortunately, I wasn’t particularly good at being Susan.

I wasn’t the brilliant student she had been. I wasn’t going to distinguish myself in mathematics. I had tried and failed at a few things that seemed to come naturally to her.

But I loved words. I loved writing. I loved stories. I loved making people laugh, or finding exactly the right way to say something.

And Ms. Prante saw that. More importantly, she helped me see it. There’s a difference between someone telling you that you’ve done something well and someone telling you that there’s something good about you.

I don’t think I understood that distinction at the time. I only knew that those seven words made me feel like I might be more than Susan Jackson’s little brother.

I might actually be somebody.

Looking back, I wonder whether I’ve spent much of my life trying to hear those words again. I’ve always loved having someone read what I’ve written and tell me it was good. Perhaps more than I should. And I’ve sometimes confused approval of my writing with approval of myself.

But I don’t think Ms. Prante was trying to give me a lifelong hunger for affirmation.

She was simply being Ms. Prante.

A woman who read Dickens aloud because she loved a good story. Who claimed, with a perfectly straight face, to have been a Munchkin. Who quietly bought theater tickets for a student who couldn’t stop talking about Camelot.

And who wrote seven words in the margin of a paper.

You are a graceful writer, Mr. Jackson.

I haven’t always been graceful. Not in my writing, and certainly not in my living.

But I still want to be. I still want to be the person MS. Prante thought I was.

And made me believe I could be.

On an impulse, I googled Nancy Prante just now. I learned she died in 2015. It’s not clear that she ever married. There are no children listed.

Oh, but she had children. Lots of them. And we loved her.

The comments section on the memorial page has been shut down, and I can’t leave a tribute. But if I could, I know what it would be. It would be the last words of A Tale of Two Cities:

It is a far better thing that I do now than I have ever done. It is a far better rest that I go to than I have ever known.

Leave a Reply