66 in 52: A One Year Chronological Journey Through the Bible

Choose Something Like a Star

I hadn’t sung the piece in nearly fifty years.

But this morning, I was thinking about being in high school chorus, I started remembering a song we sang for a choral competition called “Choose Something Like a Star.”

And I remembered it.

Not just the words or the melody. The dynamics. The phrasing. The crescendos and decrescendos. Even the places where we held a note just a little longer than the music required.

I remembered it all.

Suddenly I was seventeen again.

Some background: The piece was Randall Thompson’s setting of Robert Frost’s poem, “Choose Something Like a Star,” the final movement of Frostiana.

Our chorus director at Clarkston High School was Jacquie Holcombe. She had been Miss Kugel when I first joined chorus, and I loved her. We all did.

Mrs. Holcombe had a rule about singing a piece of music: before we sang a note, we had to understand what we were singing.

So we read Frost’s poem. We talked about it. We puzzled over it. We tried to understand what this conversation between a human being and a star was all about.

And only then did we begin to sing.

The poem begins with the speaker looking up at a star, the fairest one in sight, and asking it to say something. Anything, really. Something we can understand. Something we can learn by heart and repeat to ourselves when we’re alone.

I can still hear the opening pianissimo.

The voices were soft, reverent, almost hesitant. It was as though we really were standing beneath an immense night sky, gazing up at a distant point of light and wondering whether it might have something to say to us.

But then the questions became more insistent.

The star tells us it burns.

Well, that’s not terribly helpful.

The speaker wants to know how hot. He wants specifics. He wants scientific measurements, something that can be quantified and explained.

And the music becomes increasingly impatient.

I remember Mrs. Holcombe drawing that impatience out of us, building from the quiet wonder of the opening to an almost indignant, demanding forte staccato.

TALK FAHRENHEIT!

I can still feel the force of those two words. The sharp consonants, the emphatic rhythm, the sheer audacity of a human being demanding that a star explain itself in terms he can understand.

It was almost comical. But it was also deeply human.

We want answers. We want explanations. We want the universe to speak our language.

And the star, quite naturally, is not especially accommodating.

It offers us strangely little useful information.

But it does tell us something in the end.

Oh, that moment.

There was a fermata after those words. Mrs. Holcombe held us there, suspended between the question and the answer.

I can see her hands.

I can feel myself holding the note, watching her, waiting.

And then the music moved toward its answer.

The star, steadfast in its place, isn’t going to come down to our level. It isn’t going to make itself smaller so we can understand it better.

Instead, it asks something of us.

It asks us to rise.

It asks of us a certain height.

And the music rises with it.

The voices build, the harmonies swell, and all that wondering and questioning and demanding finally resolves into a magnificent declaration.

WE MAY CHOOSE SOMETHING LIKE A STAR!

I remember the sheer exhilaration of singing it. The full force of the chorus, all those voices becoming one, the triumphant assurance that there was something above us worth fixing our attention upon.

But the piece wasn’t finished.

That’s one of the things I remember most vividly.

After that enormous musical climax, Thompson didn’t simply end with a final thunderous chord.

The music began to recede.

The voices softened.

The declaration gave way to something quieter, almost whispered.

“To stay our minds on…”

And then, like a wave washing back into the sea, the final words faded away.

“And be staid.”

Silence.

I can still hear that silence.


It’s strange what survives in memory.

I don’t remember most of the pieces we sang in high school chorus. I don’t remember every concert, every rehearsal, or every note Mrs. Holcombe gave us about how to improve.

But I remember this.

I remember the way she made us read the poem before we could sing it.

I remember how she taught us that the dynamics weren’t just instructions printed on a page. They meant something. The pianissimo wasn’t merely quiet. It was wonder. The forte wasn’t merely loud. It was indignation. The crescendo wasn’t simply an increase in volume. It was the gathering force of an idea.

And the silence wasn’t merely the absence of sound.

It was part of the music.

I wasn’t an especially good singer. I wasn’t one of the featured performers or particularly gifted dancers. There were students in chorus with much more talent than I had.

But I loved being there.

I loved being part of something that was bigger than any one of us. And I loved those rare moments when something we’d rehearsed over and over suddenly became more than the sum of its notes and words.

I don’t know whether Mrs. Holcombe realized how deeply that particular piece affected me.

I suspect she was simply doing what a good director does: helping a group of high school students understand the music well enough to communicate it.

But she gave me something that has remained with me for the rest of my life.

She showed me that understanding something doesn’t necessarily diminish its mystery.

Sometimes it makes the mystery greater.

That matters to me more now than it did then. I’ve spent much of my adult life working with words, trying to understand ancient texts and communicate their meaning to people who are listening. I’ve learned a great deal about language, interpretation, and the limits of what we can know.

And sometimes I’ve forgotten that understanding isn’t the same thing as mastering.

There are things we can study, examine, and explain without ever exhausting their beauty.

There are things that ask us to reach beyond what we already know.

Things that ask of us a certain height.


This morning, I began describing that performance, and something unexpected happened.

I didn’t have to strain to remember.

The music was simply there.

The opening pianissimo. The demanding staccato. The fermata held just a moment longer than seemed possible. The swelling harmonies. The triumphant resolution.

And then that final, receding whisper.

For a few moments, I was standing on the risers at Clarkston High School again, watching Jacquie Holcombe’s hands, breathing with the other singers, waiting for her to bring us in.

I could hear every part of it.

I could almost feel it in my chest.

And when I finished describing it, I sat there for a moment, astonished.

There.

I just relived that entire performance.

Leave a Reply

Turn on JavaScript to leave a comment.

Exit mobile version